The topic of "Varieties of Spiritual Experiences James, Jung, Shoemaker & You" in Indianapolis, IN
Thank
you,
Jason.
Instead
of
qualifying,
I
figure
one
photo's
worth
a
thousand
words.
That
was
when
it
was
working.
When
Mike
was
kind
enough
to
extend
the
invitation
for
me
to
come
and
join
you,
I
have
been
giving,
there's
about
five
different
history
talks
that
I
give.
And
because
of
the
esteem
that
I
hold
my
nephew
in,
and
the
reason
that
I
refer
to
him
as
my
nephew
is
that
we're
both
great
fans
of
C.S.
Lewis's
The
Screw
Tape
Letter.
And
it's
my
favorite
book
on
sponsorship.
Great,
great
book.
And
anyway,
so
this
is
my
nephew
and
I
am
his
uncle.
But
I
decided
that
what
I
wanted
to
do
if
I
was
coming
to
join
is
to
see
if
there
was
something
else
that
I
could
add
to
my
knowledge.
So
what
this
particular
talk
is,
and
if
you
want,
you
can
start
the
tape
here.
Okay.
is
the
varieties
of
religious
experience.
And
so
we'll
call
this
talk
the
varieties
of
spiritual
experience.
Now,
again,
when
we're
speaking
about
these
spiritual
terms,
first
and
foremost,
we're
using
medieval
language,
mostly
language
that
came
out
of
the
King
James
Bible.
So
when
you
hear
them,
if
you've
got
some
kind
of
physical
reaction
to
it,
remember
that
it's
medieval
language.
and
don't
get
hung
up
in
those
terms.
So
the
varieties
of
spiritual
experience,
again,
we'll
get
out
of
the
medieval
and
into
something
more
contemporary.
Chronicles
of
the
twice-born.
Now,
Jason
was
kind
enough
to
read
this
letter
from
Bill
to
Ebby.
It's
a
wonderful
piece.
And
the
thing
that
Bill
was
talking
to
Jung
about
is
that
these
conversion
experiences
that
James
spoke
about,
that's
what
happens
in
AA.
And
that
they're
available
on
a
wholesale
basis,
that
this
is
not
something
that
just
happened
to
Bill
a
little
flash.
But
that
each
and
every
person
that
recovers
in
Alcoholics
Anonymous,
or
as
he
says,
the
foundation
of
such
success
as
Alcoholics
Anonymous
has
achieved,
is
laying
a
newcomer
open
to
a
transforming
experience.
And
so...
It
goes
on
to
say,
so
to
you,
Dr.
Jung,
to
Dr.
Shoemaker
of
the
Oxford
groups,
to
William
James,
and
to
my
own
physician,
Dr.
Silkworth,
we
have
AA
owe
this
tremendous
benefaction.
As
you
will
now
clearly
see,
this
astonishing
chain
of
events
actually
started
long
ago
in
your
consulting
room,
and
it
was
directly
founded
upon
your
own
humility
and
deep
perception.
So
this
is
William
James,
the
father
of
American
psychiatry.
Well,
who
was
this
guy?
Well,
he
came
from
a
very
affluent
family
in
the
Northeast.
His
father
was
a
Swedenborgian
theologian.
The
Swedenborgians
were
a
mystical
Christian
sect.
If
you
want
to
get
lost
for
8
to
15
hours,
just
Google
that
and
see
where
you
end
up.
Yeah.
He
was
the
older
brother
of
Henry
James,
and
some
of
us
that
have
been
on
the
planet
a
little
longer.
We
had
to
read
the
turn
of
the
screw
as
one
of
our...
are
books
in
an
English
class.
And
so
this
family
is
something
that's
been
part
of
the
fabric
of
American
life.
He
suffered
from
soul
sickness
his
first
30
years.
His
mother
was
so
incredibly,
he
always
had
something
going
on.
He
was
kind
of
a
hypochondriac.
And
he
wasn't
real
physically
strong,
but
he
kept
going
and
doing
all
these
really
wild
things.
Like
when
he
was
at
college,
he
decided
to
go
with
this
doctor
who
was
going
up
the
Amazon
to
figure
out
whether
or
not
trying
to
disprove
evolution.
And
he
went
along
and
was
part
of
that.
He
got
very
sick
during
that
and
came
back
to
the
United
States.
His
family
moved
around
a
bunch.
His
high
school
years,
he
was
in
like
five
different
countries.
And
so
he
wasn't
tied
to
usual
ways
that
people
get
and
assimilate
information.
Later
in
his
life,
he
became
the
first
professor
of
psychology
at
Harvard
and
later
became
the
professor
of
philosophy.
And
he
died
in
1910.
Okay.
Now,
James
concluded
that
while
the
revelations
of
the
mystic,
in
other
words,
the
spiritual
experience
of
the
mystic
hold
true
for
that
person
that
has
the
experience,
that
it's
not
something
that
anybody
else
particularly
can
experience.
In
other
words,
that
for
others,
they
are
certainly
ideas
to
be
considered,
but
they
can't
hold
claim
to
truth
without
the
personal
experience.
So
in
other
words,
you
know,
I've
got
to,
I
can
hear
you
talk
about
it,
but
I
have
to
experience
it
in
order
to
have
it
mean
something
to
me.
There's
the
varieties
of
religious
experience,
a
study
in
human
nature.
Now,
James
also
was,
when
he
wrote
this
book,
it
was
a
book
that
just
about
anybody
that
had
anything
to
do
with
psychology
or
religious
life
had
to
read.
So
it
was
a
book
that
was
just
tremendously
impactful
to
just,
you
know,
the
intellectual
evolution
of
psychology
and
religion
in
this
country.
So
you
can
imagine
that
we're
talking
about
a
time
when
just
about
everybody
was
affiliated
with
some
kind
of
church
in
this
country.
And
so
this
was
a
tremendously
impactful
book.
And
both
Shoemaker
and
Jung
and
Bookman
all
referred
to
it
and
used
it
frequently.
And
one
of
the
great
sadnesses,
I
actually
am
fortunate
enough
to
have
some
of
Frank
Bookman,
the
man
who
was
the
initiator
of
the
Oxford
group,
some
of
his
books.
And
I
had
a
chance
to
get
his
varieties,
but
with
the
other
stuff,
I
didn't
get
it.
And
now
this
book
has
become
so
very
dear
to
me.
And
I...
This
is
Clark
University
in
1909,
seven
years
after
Varieties
was
published.
And
at
this
thing
at
Clark
University,
this
is
a
picture
in
the
front
from
the
left
is
Sigmund
Freud,
William
James,
and
Carl
Jung.
There
were
having
a
fundraiser
for
Clark
University,
and
William
James
recommended
that
Sigmund
Freud
be
invited
out
to
give
a
series
of
talks.
And
so
this
is
a
picture
of
that.
And
during
that
time,
Jung
had
the
chance
to
be
with
William
James
for
a
couple
of
evenings.
I'd
like
to
read
you
a
little
piece
from
a
letter
that
he
wrote
to
his
friend,
Virginia
Payne.
Two
personalities
I
met
at
the
Clark
Conference
made
a
profound
and
lasting
impression
on
me.
One
was
Stanley
Hall,
the
president,
and
the
other
was
William
James,
who
I
met
for
the
first
time
then.
I
remember
particularly
an
evening
at
President
Hall's
House.
After
dinner,
William
James
appeared,
and
I
was
particularly
interested
in
the
personal
relation
between
Stanley
Hall
and
William
James,
since
I
gathered
from
some
of
the
remarks
of
President
Hall
that
William
James
was
not
taken
quite
seriously
on
account
of
his
interest
in
Mrs.
Piper
and
her
extrasensory
perceptions.
Stanley
Hall
had
prepared
us
that
he
had
asked
James
to
discuss
some
of
his
results
with
Mrs.
Piper
and
to
bring
some
of
his
material.
So
when
James
came,
there
was
Stanley
Hall,
Professor
Freud,
and
one
or
two
other
men
and
myself,
he
said
to
Hall,
I
brought
you
some
papers
in
which
you
might
be
interested.
And
he
put
his
hand
into
his
breast
pocket
and
drew
out
a
parcel
which,
to
our
delight,
proved
to
be
a
wad
of
dollar
bills.
Considering
Stanley
Hall's
great
services
for
the
increase
in
Wallfroller
of
Clark
University
and
his
rather
critical
remarks
as
to
James
pursuits,
it
looked
to
us
a
particularly
happy
rejoinder.
James
excused
himself
profusely
and
then
produced
the
real
papers
from
the
other
pocket.
I
spent
two
delightful
evenings
with
James
alone
and
I
was
tremendously
impressed
by
the
cleanness
of
his
mind
and
the
complete
absence
of
intellectual
prejudices.
Stanley
Hall
was
an
equally
clear-headed
man,
but
of
a
decidedly
academic
brand.
The
conference
was
noteworthy
on
the
account
of
the
fact
that
this
was
the
first
time
that
Professor
Freud
had
an
immediate
contact
with
America.
It
was
the
first
official
recognition
of
the
existence
of
psychoanalysis,
and
it
meant
a
great
deal
to
him
because
recognition
in
Europe
for
him
was
regrettably
scarce.
I
was
a
young
man
then.
I
lectured
about
association
tests
in
a
case
of
child
psychology.
I
was
also
interested
in
parapsychology,
and
my
discussions
with
William
James
were
chiefly
about
this
subject
and
about
the
psychology
of
religious
experience.
Now,
Jung
also
emphasized
the
importance
of
balance
and
harmony,
and
he
cautioned
that
modern
humans
rely
too
heavily
on
science
and
logic,
and
would
benefit
from
integrating
spirituality
and
an
appreciation
of
the
unconscious
realm.
Here's
another
fan
of
James
Sam
Shoemaker,
who
was
an
Oxford
group
leader.
He
was
the
rectory
of
Calvary
Church
and
the
founder
of
Calvary
Mission,
and
he
was
a
spiritual
mentor
to
Bill
Wilson
and
many
of
the
original
members
of
Alcoholics
Anonymous.
In
his
book,
Realizing
Religion,
Shoemaker's
talking
about
having
a
scientific
definition
of
what
is
conversion.
So
when
I
say
conversion,
I'm
not
saying
what
you
think
I'm
saying.
But
this
is
what,
this
is,
this
is
Shoemaker's
definition.
I
think
it's
a
good
one
for
us
to
work
from.
The
process,
gradual
or
sudden,
by
which
is
self,
Hitherto
divided
and
consciously
wrong,
inferior,
and
unhappy
becomes
unified,
consciously
right,
and
happy.
So
this
book,
the
varieties
of
religious
experience,
a
lot
of
people
say,
That's
the
toughest
book
I've
ever
had
to
read.
Well,
it's
a
book
that's
a
series
of
lectures,
and
they're
all
interrelated,
but
it's
really
good
if
you've
got
a
short
attention
span
and
a
little
ADD.
or
a
little
post-methodrine
stress
disorder,
to
start
where
Bill
Wilson
started.
Start
in
conversion,
which
is
in
the
middle
of
the
book.
I
think
it's
like
the
seventh
lecture.
And
then
read
back
through
conversion
and
then
back
before
it,
and
end
of
mysticism
and
the
like.
And
it's
a
fascinating,
fascinating
read
if
you're
a
strange
chap
with
a
queer
idea
of
fun.
But
if
you
sit
down
to
read
it
like
a
book,
you
may
want
to
just
get
out
razor
blades
and
run
a
warm
tub.
Now
in
it,
James
talks
about
the
fact
that
God
has
two
families.
Of
the
children
on
this
earth,
there
are
the
once
born
and
there
are
the
twice
born.
The
once
born.
They
see
God
not
as
a
judge,
not
as
a
glorious
potentate,
but
as
an
animating
spirit
of
a
beautiful
and
harmonious
world,
healthy-minded.
They
generally
have
no
metaphysical
tendencies.
They
don't
look
back
into
themselves.
And
they're
not
too
distressed
by
their
own
imperfections.
Then
there
are
the
twice
born.
These
people
are
wrong
living.
They
have
impotent
aspirations.
What
I
do,
that
I
do
not,
but
what
I
hate
that
I
do,
says
St.
Paul.
They're
self-loathing,
self-despairing.
An
unintelligible
and
intolerable
burden
to
which
one
is
mysteriously
the
heir.
Do
you
go
to
meetings
with
people
like
this?
Huh?
Now,
who
are
the
candidates
for
this
conversion
process?
In
other
words,
of
these
twice-born
folks,
they're
these
folks
that
are
preoccupied
with
themselves.
They
hate
what
they're
doing.
They
are
completely
unsatisfied
all
the
time,
and
they're
always
seeing
where
they're
wrong.
Well,
so
to
begin
with,
there
are
two
things
in
the
mind
of
the
candidate
for
conversions.
First,
the
present
incompleteness
or
wrongness,
the
sin
in
which
he
is
eager
to
escape,
and
the
second
is
the
present
ideal
that
he
longs
to
compass.
In
other
words,
I've
got
to
have
something
not
only
that
I
want
to
get
out
of,
but
that
I
want
to
grow
too.
So
in
these
varieties
of
spiritual
experience,
James
talks
about
there
basically
being
two
types,
two
categories.
One
is
the
educational
variety,
and
he
describes
it
as
a
moral
incubation,
that
what
happens
is
it's
kind
of
like
an
athlete
who
keeps
engaging
in
a
sport,
and
there
may
come
a
day
when
all
at
once
the
game
seems
to
play
itself
through
him,
or
like
a
musician.
who
practices
and
practices
and
practices,
and
then
in
performing
somehow,
it
all
comes
together
and
comes
through
them.
That
what
this
is
is
that
it's
a
process
of
education,
it's
a
process
of
being
immersed
in
something
and
growing
through
it.
And
then
there's
the
sudden
experience.
Now,
what
James
says
about
this
is
that
it
unconsciously
develops,
until
it's
ready
to
play
a
controlling
part
when
it
makes
a
sudden
eruption
into
conscious
life.
So
in
other
words,
the
same
thing's
going
on.
There's
something
happening
that
the
conscious
mind
is
not
aware
of,
but
when
it
comes,
it's
now.
Now,
in
these
sudden
spiritual
experience,
oftentimes
voices
are
often
heard.
Lights
are
seen,
visions
witnessed,
automatic
motor
phenomenon
occur.
And
it
always
seems
after
the
surrender
of
the
personal
will,
as
if
an
exterraneous
higher
power
had
flooded
in
and
taken
possession.
Oh,
there's
higher
power.
How'd
they
steal
that
from
Alcoholics
Anonymous?
The
term's
been
used
for
a
long
time
by
a
lot
of
really
wonderful
people.
And
then
what
about
the
agnostic?
Well,
James
said
that
what
the
agnostic
does
is
that
they
just
out
front
veto
faith.
as
something
weak
and
shameful.
And
they're
afraid
to
use
their
instincts.
In
many
persons,
such
inhibitions
are
never
overcome.
They
make
that
decision
and
that's
it.
But
this
may
only
be
a
temporary
inhibition,
even
late
in
life.
Some
thaw,
some
release
takes
place,
and
such
cases
suggest
that
sudden
conversion
is
by
a
miracle.
You've
been
sitting
with
Earl
for
35
years
in
the
meeting.
And
he
always
says,
I
don't
know
anything
about
this
God
stuff.
And
then
one
day,
something
happens.
And
if
that's
not
miraculous,
what
is?
So
what's
the
test?
Well,
the
test
that
James
gave
is
that
impossible
things
are
possible.
New
energies
and
endurances
are
shown.
The
personality
is
changed.
The
man
is
born
anew.
Whether
or
not
his
psychological
idiosyncrasies
are
what
gives
shape
to
his
metamorphosis.
They
didn't
smoke
any
methamphetamine
for
a
whole
day.
That's
it.
I
didn't
have
anything
to
drink,
and
I'm
in
Indianapolis.
I
mean,
my
God.
So
what's
a
good
example
of
a
sudden
experience?
Well,
in
the
varieties
of
religious
experience,
James
refers
to
one,
S.H.
Hadley.
who
after
his
conversion
became
an
active
and
useful
rescuer
of
drunkards
in
New
York.
In
Down
on
Water
Street,
his
autobiography
he
wrote,
It
isn't
the
last
drink
that
hurts
a
man
or
the
fourth
or
fifth.
It's
the
first
drink
that
ruins
a
man.
Well,
that's
Alcoholics
Anonymous.
This
book
was
written
in
1890.
Where'd
they
get
it?
Here's
a
picture
of
the
book
down
in
Water
Street
by
S.H.
Hadley.
The
story
of
16
years
of
life
and
work
in
the
Water
Street
mission,
a
sequel
to
the
life
of
Jerry
McCauley.
Jerry
McCauley
was
the
guy
who
established
the
first
Bowery
mission
in
New
York.
And
here's
a
picture
of
S.H.
Hadley.
I
love
this.
Yours
for
the
lost.
I
believe
that's
on
Lorenza's
new
card.
And
again,
in
this,
Hadley
has
this
white
light
experience.
Although
up
to
that
moment
my
soul
had
been
filled
with
indescribable
gloom,
I
felt
the
glorious
feeling
of
the
noonday
sunshine
into
my
heart.
I
felt
I
was
a
free
man.
And
from
that
moment
till
this,
I've
never
wanted
a
drink
of
whiskey
nor
seen
enough
money
to
make
me
take
one.
And
doesn't
that
sound
a
lot
like
I
stood
on
the
mountaintop?
I
felt
like
a
wind
blew
through
me.
And
so
here
Bill
is.
He's
sitting
in
towns.
He's
just
had
this
huge
emotional
experience.
You
know,
he's
conscious
of
the
presence
of
God.
He's
wondering
if
he's
crazy.
And
his
buddy
brings
a
book,
this
varieties
of
religious
experience,
and
goes,
here
it
is.
You've
had
this.
And
he
reads
it
and
he
goes,
yeah.
And
that's
why
this
book
was
so
important
to
Bill.
He
used
to
say
that
what
it
did
is
it
gave
him
the
cash
value.
And
in
this
conversion
section,
the
conversion
are
two
lectures.
What
James
does
is
he
talks
about
a
lot
of
different
types
of
conversion
experiences
that
people
have,
both
gradual
and
sudden.
And
here's
a
picture
of
the
Water
Street
Mission.
And
Hadley's
there
in
the
front
with
a
stick
and
the
big...
The
big
mustache.
Some
people
can
really
grow
mustaches,
aren't
they
had
joy?
Now,
James
gets
tagged
with
this
line,
but
it's
a
quote
that
he
said,
that
the
only
radical
remedy
for
dipsomania
is
religomania.
Is
it
saying
I've
heard
quoted
from
some
medical
man?
A
lot
of
people
say
that
that's
a
quote
that
James
came
out.
For
those
of
you
who
don't
know,
one
of
the
old
terms
for
alcoholism
was
dipsomania,
where
the
little
thing
about...
for
the
older
people
to
say,
don't
be
a
dip.
Well,
that's
from
being
a
dipsomaniac,
not
from
dancing
poorly
in
Philadelphia.
So,
twice-born.
Now,
there
are
some
wonderful
other
things,
books
that
had
to
do
with
this
concept
of
the
twice-born.
And
one
of
them
is
this
book
called
Twice
Born
Men.
It's
a
clinic
in
regeneration,
a
footnote
in
narrative
to
Professor
William
James's
varieties
of
religious
experience
by
Harold
Begby.
And
this
is
a
wonderful
book.
Begby
wrote
about
the
work
of
the
Salvation
Army
in
London.
And
in
it
are
nine
personal
stories,
which
when
you
read
them,
read
very
much
like
the
ones
that
are
in
the
back
of
our
book.
They're,
you
know,
what
it
used
to
be
like,
what
happened
and
what
they're
like
now.
And
there's
the
puncher
and
there's
the
cop
basher.
In
I
think
the
second
edition,
there's
Annie
the
Cop
Fighter,
you
know,
of
our
book,
Alcoholics
Anonymous.
There's
the
criminal.
And
then
my
personal
favorite,
OBD,
old
blind
drunk.
And
his
story
is
just
great.
So,
and
he
talks
about
these
people
having
contact
with
the
Salvation
Army,
having
a
conversion
experience,
and
then,
you
know,
going
on
with
their
lives.
Begby
said
on
conversion,
he
says,
conversion
is
the
only
means
by
which
a
radically
bad
person
can
be
changed
into
a
radically
good
person.
Pretty
close,
huh?
Oh,
I
know.
In
Indianapolis,
you
guys
aren't
radically
bad.
Sorry.
Now,
a
few
years
later,
Begby
came
in
contact
with
the
Oxford
group,
and
he
got
lit
up
by
what
went
on,
and
he
wrote
a
sequel
called
More
Twice
Born
Men,
narratives
of
a
recent
movement
in
the
spirit
of
personal
religion.
And
in
the
United
States,
this
was
introduced
as
the
life
changers.
Now,
James
and
the
varieties
of
religious
experience,
and
so
did
Paul
and
so
did
Jesus.
They
all
said
that
you
will
know
whether
or
not
something
is
from
God,
or
whatever
you
want
to
call
it,
by
its
fruits.
By
its
fruits,
they
will
be
known.
And
in
varieties
of
religious
experience,
James
brings
this
home
quite
clearly
that,
you
know,
how
do
we
know
whether
it's
true,
a
true
religious
experience
or
not?
What
happens
out
of
it?
So
let's
talk
about
the
experiences
that
some
of
these
people
from
our
history
had.
Now,
Frank
Bukman,
who
in
Life
Changers
is
called
The
Life
Changer,
he
has
this
experience
in
the
chapel
at
Kesek,
where
he's
convicted
of
his
own
sin
of
hating
the
people
that
he
thought
had
wronged
him.
And
what
were
the
results
of
this
experience?
Well,
he
ends
up
doing
some
really
wonderful
work
at
Penn
State
University
and
helping
a
lot
of
people
to
a
spiritual
experience,
coming
up
with
a
whole
set
of
steps.
And
then
this
morphs
into
what
was
called
the
first
century
Christian
fellowship
that
was
an
international
movement
of
people
that
was
trying
to...
Trying
to
introduce
this
concept
that
if
you've
got
a
problem
in
your
life,
in
your
home,
in
your
business,
in
anything,
that
if
you
clean
yourself
up
spiritually,
that
all
these
other
areas
will
clear
up.
But
you've
got
to
clean
yourself
up
spiritually
first.
They
also
did
a
lot
of
work
going
around
working
with
missionary
communities.
telling
folks
that
were
working
with
others.
Again,
trying
to
do
the
key
person
strategy.
How
can
they
touch
the
most
people?
Well,
when
they
went
to
work
with
missionary
communities,
they'd
teach
this
to
them
so
that
hopefully
the
Christian
message
that
they
were
able
to
transmit
would
have
power
to
it.
This
became
the
Oxford
group,
out
of
which
Alcoholics
Anonymous
springs.
moral
rearmament,
which
if
you
were
here
earlier
today
I
spoke
about
and
all
the
great
international
things
that
have
happened
out
of
that.
And
now
it's
called
initiatives
of
change.
So,
I
mean,
out
of
the
fruits
of
this
one
man's
experience,
how
many
millions
of
lives
are
touched?
William
Gilliland.
Now,
his
experience
was
of
the
educational
variety.
He's
hanging
out
with
Bookman.
They're
talking
about
changing
your
life.
He's
kind
of
going
along
with
it.
It's
okay.
He
gets
stuck
in
a
place
where
he
can't
get
a
drink
and
has
an
experience
where
he
stops
drinking.
But
the
reason
that
I
put
this
as
an
educational
is
is
he
has
the
ramping
up
to
it
and
then
bang
it
happens.
And,
of
course,
he
went
all
over
the
world
as
part
of
Bukman's
team
in
different
places
talking
about
what
happened
in
his
family
and
about
what
happened
with
his
drinking
problem.
And
that's
why
Bukman
and
the
Oxford
group
were
not
interested
in
Bill
Wilson.
They
had
hundreds
and
hundreds
of
people
who
had
quit
doing
drugs,
doing
liquor,
smoking,
doing
strange
sex.
They
had
people
that
had
all
kinds
of
problems
solved.
Right.
So
when
Bill
says,
well,
send
me
a
drunk,
they're
going,
well,
we
got
people
that
have
drinking
problems,
but
they
got
lots
of
other
problems
besides
just
drinking.
But
Bill
was
obsessed
because
his
experience,
he
had
the
vision
of
each
sufferer
passing
on
to
the
next.
Fortunately
for
us,
Sam
Shoemaker
backed
that
experience.
Now,
oh,
here's
Shoemaker
on
Bookman,
and
this
is
in
more
twice-born
men.
He's
called,
Sam
is
called
the
Virginian
in
that
book.
They
were
all
anonymous
in
the
beginning.
They
were
anonymous.
The
Oxford
Group
was
probably
anonymous,
the
first
15
years
of
any
publicity
about
them.
Frank
would
only
say,
you
can
write
about
me,
but
you
have
to
use
FB.
Yeah.
And
anyway,
Sam's
called
the
Virginian
because
that's
where
he
was
from.
And
on
Shoemaker,
or
Bookman
on
Shoemich.
Stop.
Breathe.
Shoemaker
on
Frank
Bookman.
The
truth
is
the
man
is
a
born
mystic.
Get
him
alone
and
you'll
realize
this
at
once.
And
you
also
realize
the
truth
of
what
James
says,
that
we've
got
to
accept
the
experience
of
the
mystic
as
a
valid
experience.
F.B.
made
a
tremendous
impression
on
me.
His
simple
insistence
on
the
power
of
sin
to
wall
out
any
vital
consciousness
of
God
was
irresistible.
He
showed
me
quite
mercilessly
my
spiritual
impotence
in
the
lives
of
other
men.
This
is
a
picture
of
Frank
at
Kuling,
China.
This
is
the
place.
I
actually
have
one
of
my
treasures
that
I
have
the
notes
of
Frank's
talk
that
he
gave
at
Kuling,
and
this
is
the
talk
that
Sam
Shoemaker
was
at.
Sam
was
there.
He
was
a...
From
a
well-to-do
family
in
Virginia,
he
decided
that
he
was
going
to
go
into
the
ministry
because
it
was
a
good
thing
and
it
would
be
a
wonderful
thing
to
do.
And
he
went
along
and
part
of
the
deal
was
if
you
were
going
to
be
a
man
of
the
cloth,
he
had
to
go
someplace.
And
he
ended
up
in
China
because
Princeton
University
had
a
school
in
China.
And
so
he's
got
a
men's
Bible
study.
And
for
the
first
time
in
his
life,
Sam
is
not
being
successful.
These
guys
just
aren't
getting
it.
And
he's
having
a
real
hard
time
with
the
language.
And
he
really
doesn't
like
being
in
China.
He
doesn't
like
the
food.
The
fact
that
God
and
pig
are
very
similar
sounding,
it's
very
difficult.
And
it's
just
awful.
So
anyway,
he'd
started
out.
He
had
about
50
guys
in
his
class.
He's
down
to
about
12.
And
he
goes
and
he
hears
Frank
talk.
And
he
walks
up
to
Frank
afterward.
He
says,
that's
wonderful.
He
said,
why
don't
you
do
this?
Why
don't
you
come?
I
got
this
one
guy,
back
to
the
keyman
strategy.
You
got
this
one
guy.
And
if
you
didn't
get
through
to
him,
I
know
that
his
change
will
produce
results
and
everybody
will
come
back
and
will
be
successful
and
be
a
wonderful
thing.
Help
me
out.
Would
you
please?
Frank
Lick-Sidaman
said,
what's
wrong
with
you?
That
you
cannot
transmit
a
message
of
power.
Sam
was
just
a
little
upset.
Yeah.
He
left
in
a
rage.
I
mean,
this
guy's
from
Pennsylvania.
He's
a
Lutheran.
I
mean,
and
he's
telling
me
that
I
can't
transmit
a
message
of
power.
What
the
heck's
wrong
with
him?
And
Sam
could
not
get
that
out
of
his
mind.
And
all
night
he
thought
about
it.
And
he
realized
that
he'd
really
probably
only
given
about
65,
maybe
70%
of
himself
to
God.
And
he
could
see
that
other
30%
really,
really
clearly.
And
that
night
he
got
down
on
his
knees
and
he
said,
you
know,
not
in
an
emotional
desperation,
but
as
a
conscious
act,
I
can't
do
it.
I
need
your
help.
The
next
day
he
went
and
he
told
Frank
exactly
the
experience
that
he
had.
He
and
Frank
walked
and
talked
and
he
went
back
to
his
class
the
next
day.
And,
you
know,
Frank
said,
well,
you
got
to
go,
you
know,
make
restitution.
And
so
he
gets
up
in
front
of
this
class
of...
Chinese
guy
and
he
says,
I'm
really
sorry.
I've
been
talking
a
good
game,
but
I've
only
been
playing
at
about
70%.
I've
been
talking
down
to
you
because
I
felt
uncomfortable.
Will
you
please
forgive
me
and
allow
me
to
try
and
share
all
of
myself?
And
the
most
amazing
thing
happened.
These
guys
responded
and
the
class
grew.
And
out
of
that,
period
of
regeneration
for
the
next
almost
40
years,
or
30
years,
31
years,
Sam
and
Frank
went
all
over
the
world.
My
friend
Willard
Hunter,
who
came
into
the
Oxford
Group
in
1936,
who's
still
alive,
said
that
they
really
needed
both
of
each
other
quite
badly,
and
that
it
was
a
shame
that
they
split
in
1941.
A
lot
of
people
like
to
say
that
it
had
something
to
do
with
some...
that
Sam
wanted
to
be
something
in
the
hierarchy
of
the
Episcopal
Church.
But
if
you've
ever
been
involved
in
a
church,
I
mean,
Sam
had
given
all
this
time
and
energy
to
the
Oxford
group.
They
had
the
church,
Calvary
Church,
was
the
center
of
the
Oxford
Group
movement
in
the
United
States,
the
clearinghouse
for
all
the
literature.
And
when
the
movement
went
from
the
Oxford
group
to
moral
rearmament
from
being
a
thing
of
one
informed
Christian
talking
to
the
next,
to
an
international
movement
of
trying
to
work
in
the
political
arena,
Sam
couldn't
support
that.
He's
busy
running
this
place
on
other
people's
money.
So
that's
why
there
was
this
schism
between
them,
but
they
were
really
close
for
about
34
years.
So
I
like
to
say
that
Sam
had
an
educational
variety.
Sam
wrote
a
book
later
on
called
twice-born
ministers,
talking
about
exactly
this
experience
and
other
people
that
had
the
same
type
of
experience.
He
asked
his
friend
Harold
Begby
if
he
could
use
the
title,
Twice
Born
Ministers.
And
the
quote
that
he's
got
on
the
front
of
this
story,
is
a
quote
from
James,
and
it
says,
the
real
deliverance,
the
twice-born
folk,
insist,
and
must
be
one
of
universal
application.
I've
got
to
give
it
all,
all
of
it.
So
Sam
wrote
a
lot
of
wonderful
sermons,
and
they're
collected
in
different
books.
And
the
reason
that
I
like
to
acquaint
you
with
him
more
is
to
give
you
more
of
a
feel
about
the
Oxford
group
and
the
spiritual
experiences
that
came
about
in
the
group.
In
confident
faith,
what
Sam
said
is
that
the
decision
that
we
need
to
make,
that
religion
is
a
risk.
Faith
is
not...
sight,
it's
a
high
gamble.
There
are
only
true
alternatives
here.
God
is
or
he
isn't.
You
leap
one
way
or
the
other.
Sound
familiar?
Again,
as
God,
as
you
understand
him.
So
they
prayed
together,
opening
their
minds
to
as
much
of
God
as
they
understood,
removing
first
the
hindrance
of
self-will.
surrender
as
much
of
himself
as
he
could
to
as
much
of
Christ
as
he
understood.
And
again,
in
the
beginning,
we
know
only
a
little.
I
mean,
think
about
how
much
of
yourself
that
you
gave
the
first
time
you
made
a
surrender
in
Alcoholics
Anonymous.
And
think
about
how
much
more
you
know
about
yourself
and
how
much
more
you're
able
to
give
to
your
higher
power
now.
Action.
I
love
this.
This
is
from
realizing
religion,
1928.
Sam
wrote,
A
moral
experiment...
is
worth
ten
times
an
intellectual
investigation
into
apprehending
spiritual
truth.
Obedience
is
as
much
the
organ
of
spiritual
understanding
as
reason.
Don't
drink.
He
got
to
be
obedient
first
before
we
didn't
get
much
anyplace
else.
So
here
are
the
types
of
conversion.
The
sudden
are...
S.H.
Hadley,
Frank
Bookman,
Bud
Firestone,
Charles
Clap,
Roland
Hazard,
Bill
Wilson,
Marty
Mann.
The
gradual
are
Sam
Shoemaker,
Harry
Hadley,
Ebby
Thatcher,
Bob
Smith,
and
William
Gilliland.
Now,
interesting
to
me
is
that
the
fruits
of
the
gradual
being
Sam
Shoemaker...
touch
all
these
other
people
that
are
on
the,
or
most
of
the
other
people
that
are
on
the
left-hand
side.
And
the
other
thing
that's
really
interesting
is,
you
know,
here
he
is,
he's
the
minister
at
this
very
well-known,
big,
Episcopal
Church
in
New
York
City.
So
who's
he
end
up
touching?
A
lot
of
very
wealthy
guys.
In
a
wonderful
piece,
which
you'll
find
in
A.A.grapvine.org.
Or
in...
Best
of
the
Grapevine,
there's
an
article
called
The
Spiritual
Angle,
written
in
my
195
by
Shoemaker,
and
then
he's
talking
about
the
steps
of
the
program.
And
he
says
that
when
Bill
comes
to,
we
came
to
believe
that
a
power
greater
than
ourselves
could
restore
us
to
sanity.
He
says
the
basis
of
this
belief
is
not
theoretical.
It
was
evidential.
before
us
were
people
in
whose
lives
the
beginning
of
transformation
had
taken
place.
You
could
question
the
interpretation
of
the
experience,
but
you
could
not
question
the
transformation
itself.
We
sit
in
the
meetings
and
we
hear
all
these
people
that
are
describing
their
personal
experiences,
drinking
and
not
drinking
and
all
that
stuff.
And
we
may
think,
well,
it's
a
little
squirrely
the
way
they're
putting
that,
but
you
can't.
they're
not
drinking.
Something's
going
on.
So
here's
Harry
Hadley.
He
had
a
sudden
experience.
His
father,
S.H.
Hadley,
that
was
in
the
varieties
of
religious
experience,
had
wanted
his
son's
heated
band
in
his
family
at
a
young
age.
And
there
was
nothing
that
he
wanted
more
than
for
his
son
to
get
sober.
His
son
was
a
drunkard
and
a
gambler
and
just
a
horrible
rake.
And
he
wanted
nothing
to
do
with
his
old
man.
But
days
after
his
father
died,
Harry
had
an
experience.
And
he
quit
drinking,
and
he
took
up
the
family
business.
And
he
went
around
being
a
temperance
preacher
and
did
a
lot
of
wonderful
work.
And
he
was
tired
of
being
on
the
road,
and
he
came
back
to
New
York.
And
Sam
Shoemaker
was
starting
the
Calvary
Mission,
and
he
said,
come
on
and
join
me.
And
he
had
this
amazing
ministry
at
the
Calvary
Mission
helping
drunks
off
the
street.
He
worked
with
thousands
of
alcoholics,
and
he
was
especially
close
to
Sebrough
Graves,
Shep
Cornell,
Tex-Franisco,
and
Charles
Clap,
Jr.
All
people
who
were
sober
in
the
Oxford
group
when
a
certain
stock
speculator,
he
was
not
a
broker,
rolls
in.
Bud
Firestone.
Bud
Firestone
was
a
sudden
experience.
He
had
it
as
a
result
of
a
conversation
with
Sam
Shoemaker
on
a
train
from
Denver.
Right.
He
was
an
Oxford
group
member.
Another
reason
that
he's
special
to
us
is
that
his
family
was
very
close
to
the
rector
at
St.
James
Episcopal
Church
in
Akron,
Ohio,
the
Reverend
Walter
Tunks,
the
same
guy
that
when
the
stock
speculators
is
looking
for
somebody
to
call
instead
of
going
in
to
get
a
ginger
ale
and...
meet
a
woman
who
understands,
he
gets
a
hold
of
Walter
Tunks.
Firestone
also
attended
Oxford
Group
meetings
with
Henrietta
Cyberling
and
Ann
and
Bob
Smith.
And
he
was
responsible.
His
change,
his
conversion
experience
was
responsible
for
the
Oxford
group
coming
to
Akron,
getting
things
rolling
there,
having
an
infrastructure
of
meeting
set
so
that
when
Bill
comes
and
he's
thirsty,
he's
got
someplace
to
go.
He's
got
friends.
Pretty
stunning.
This
is
another
one.
Charles
Clap
Jr.
He
wrote
a
couple
of
great
books.
One's
the
big
bender.
This
is
written
again
before
Bill's
written
the
big
book.
And
I
love
it
because
he
talks
about
the
Oxford
group
and
drink
it
and
go
into
meetings.
And
he's...
He
was
a
stockbroker.
That
little
illustration
in
the
book
is
from
the
chapter,
gin
and
religion
mixed.
Anyway,
claps
in
a
little
bit
of
a
jam.
His
wife
didn't
really
want
to
give
him
a
divorce.
He's
going
to
the
meetings,
but
he's
really
not
that
interested.
So
he
decides
to
go
and
see
Sam.
He
has
a
personal
interview
with
Sam.
Goes
to
Sam's
office.
Here's
a
great
picture
of
Sam
in
his
office
at
Calvary
Church.
It
was
really
fun.
When
I
got
this
picture,
it
was
the
one
there
on
the
left,
and
I
go,
I
know
that
guy.
And
when
I
blew
it
up,
sure
enough,
it's
Bill
Wilson.
It
was
a
little
picture
of
Bill
that
was
in
Sam's
office.
So
in
it,
during
the
whole
time
he's
talking
to
Sam,
what
Charlie
Claps
really
thinking
about
is
this
date
he's
got
with
this
dolly.
And
so
he
finally
gets
himself
out
of
there,
and
he
says,
I
departed
Girlward.
Leaning
back
in
the
taxi,
I
lit
a
cigarette.
Pugh.
It's
a
wonder
that
I
didn't
make
an
ass
out
of
myself
and
surrender
my
life
for
some
full
thing.
And
then
suddenly,
the
streetlights
grew
dim.
The
most
overwhelming,
powerful
feeling
gripped
me.
Something
inside
me
said,
you
must
surrender
your
life
to
me.
So
it's
really
fun.
It's
the
flip
of
bills.
It's
dark.
But
yet
the
spirit's
there.
Roland
Hazard.
I
like
to
say
that
Roland
had
the
educational
varieties
hanging
out
with
with...
Carl
Jung,
he's
tried
all
these
different
things,
and
he's
drinking.
He
had
two
profound
changes.
He
had
two
different
experiences
where
he
sobered
up
in
the
Oxford
group.
But
the
one
that
I
like
to
refer
to
is
when
he's
on
the
train,
he's
been
drinking
and
going
to
meetings
since
he's
gotten
back
from
Paris,
and
he's
on
the
train,
and
he's
reading
Vic
Kitchens'
book,
I
was
a
pagan.
And
he's
reading
about,
you
know,
liking
every
kind
of,
you
know,
narcotic
stimulant
and
everything
else.
And
he
identified
in
death
at
depth.
And
he
had
a
surrender
on
the...
Now,
his
experience,
not
only
did
he
help
lots
of
people
in
the
Oxford
group.
I
mean,
he
was
a
big-time
speaker.
I
mean,
he
was
a
famous
man.
And
one
of
the
things
that
later
on
is
the
Oxford
group
changed
from
anonymity
to
getting
the
people
that
had
some
cachet
out
and
doing
the
talking
because
maybe
they
would
bring
more
people
in
and
more
people
would
have
a
chance
to
change.
And,
of
course,
we
owe
him
the
great
thing
because
he
helped
Eby.
One
of
the
things
that
people
always
say
to
me
is,
did
Roland
die
sober?
Did
Debbie
die
sober?
What
was
wrong
with
them?
I
think
it's
the
height
of
arrogance
for
us
to
view
these
people
who
made
a
surrender
and
had
an
experience
of
change
in
their
lives
in
the
Oxford
group
from
the
Alcoholics
Anonymous
perspective.
They
were
not
in
a
group
that
talked
about
having
a
sobriety
date
and
permanent
abstinence
on
an
all-time
basis.
They
were
talking
about
having
their
lives
change
and
living
from
a
spiritual
center.
And
some
of
them
drank
and
some
of
them
didn't
and
this
and
that
and
another
thing.
But
we
really,
I
think,
do
a
great
disservice
not
only
to
them,
but
to
other
members
of
our
fellowship
that
maybe
save
our
lives
that
may
or
may
not
have
been
here
on
an
all-time
basis.
Of
course,
there's
Ebby.
His
was
an
educational
variety.
He
had
a
couple
weeks
with
Roland
running
around
speaking
at
meetings,
and
they
took
him
down
to
Calvary
Church.
He
was
there
for
a
month.
And
he
went
to
visit
Bill,
and
he
had
six
weeks.
And
Bill
knew
that
clearly
this
worked.
It
was
forever.
And
sometimes,
you
know,
do
we
take
for
granted
this
amazing
miracle
that
we
have
of
being
sober
a
day
at
a
time
put
together?
And
of
course,
our
friend
Bill
Wilson,
he
had
a
sudden
experience.
He
had
a
sudden
release
from
his
drinking
obsession,
a
co-founder
of
AA.
He
establishes
this
format
for
personal
change,
which
he
stole
basically
from
the
Oxford
group,
facilitating
the
moral
ripening.
Because
isn't
that
what
we
do
when
we
come
to
meetings?
Yes.
We're
sitting
in
there.
We
don't
know
where
we
are.
We
don't
know
what's
going
on.
And
here
are
these
women
and
men
telling
their
stories
of
how
it
is
that
they
changed.
And
in
that
process,
this
moral
incubation
happens.
We
identify
and
gradually
we
stop
drinking.
Dr.
Bob.
Bob
has
the
educational
variety.
He's
drinking
and
going
to
meetings
for
a
few
years.
And,
you
know,
I'm
fortunate
that
I
did
not
get
sober
in
only
the
164
pages
of
the
big
book.
When
I
got
sober,
we
could
read
it
unsupervised.
And
Dr.
Bob's
nightmare
is
a
wonderful
part
of
my
life.
And
in
it,
he
talks
about
that
unlike
the
others
of
the
crowd,
the
thirst
never
left
him
for
the
first
two
and
a
half
years.
It
was
almost
always
with
me.
And
yet
he
works
with
thousands
of
alcohol,
co-founder
of
Alcoholics
Anonymous.
So,
again,
it
doesn't
matter,
sudden
or
gradual.
What's
the
fruits?
And
with
this
group,
it
seems
that,
you
know,
the
people
that
have
the
educational
variety
seem
to
touch
a
lot
of
people.
And
then
Marty
Mann.
Now,
if
you
haven't
read
a
feminine
victory,
again,
it's
not
in
the
first
164
pages,
And
there's
a
marvelous
biography
out
by
Marty
Mann.
And
Marty
Mann
had
this
incredible
experience.
She
was
this
debutante,
lots
of
money.
She
could
drink
really,
really
good.
She
ended
up
going
to
Europe
and
hanging
out
there
and
being
a
socialite.
Liquor
finally
gets
to
her
so
she
comes
back
to
America
thinking
that
she's
going
to
get
better.
She
can't
understand
what's
wrong
with
her.
She
can't
understand
what's
wrong
with
her.
There
is
no
concept
of
alcoholism
as
a
disease
in
most
of
the
folks.
She's
gone
to
everybody.
She's
gone
to
everyone.
She's
run
out
of
all
resources.
She
ends
up
at
Blythewood
Manor.
And
the
only
reason
that
she
was
there
is
a
friend
burned
a
favor
and
got
her
in
with
this
guy
by
the
name
of
Harry
Tebow.
Dr.
Tebow
was
one
of
the
people
that
got
one
of
the
multi-lift
copies
of
the
book,
Alcoholics
Anonymous,
one
of
the
review
copies.
And
he
got
sick.
He's
a
busy
doctor.
He
got
sick.
So
he
decides
to
look
through
his
correspondence.
And
when
he
takes
a
look
at
this
thing,
Alcoholics
Anonymous,
he
goes,
oh
my
gosh.
And
he
brings
it
down
to
Marty.
And
he
says,
you
read
this
thing.
And
so
Marty
starts
reading
it.
And
she
can't
believe
it.
She's
spent
all
of
her
life
reacting
to
this
thing
where
she
was
sure
she
was
insane,
but
people
like
you
just
don't
ever
get
it.
She's
been
everywhere,
and
suddenly
there
are
all
these
people
like
her.
And
then
there's
this
God
stuff.
Oh,
not
that.
But
she
keeps
reading
and
she
keeps
identifying.
And
then
all
of
a
sudden
she
throws
the
book
away
and
she
goes
off.
And
over
a
couple
days,
she's
having
some
conflict
with
one
of
the
people
at
the
hospital.
And
she's,
I
know
what
I'll
do.
I'll
just
go
out
and
drink
at
her.
I'll
leave
the
insane
asylum,
go
get
a
bottle.
I'll
show
her.
And
she
goes
back
and
she
just
happens
to
pick
the
book
up
and
she
starts
to
read
where
it
talks
about,
you
know,
drinking
at
somebody
and
how
insane
that
is
like
hitting
yourself
with
a
hammer.
And
when
she
has
that,
when
she
sees
that,
she
has
this
incredible
white
light
experience.
Now
the
difficulty
for
Marty
is
that
when
she
has
this
experience,
you
know,
She's
had
something
like
it
before,
and
the
last
time
she
had
it,
what
she
did
is
she
walked
out
of
a
second
floor
window,
so
she's
convinced
that
she's
insane.
She
goes
running
back
to
Tebow.
She
says,
Tebow,
you
know,
this
is
what
happened.
Everything
became
clear.
Everything
became
still.
The
colors
became
different.
What's
wrong
with
me?
And
Tebow
says
to
her,
relax.
Relax.
That
sounds
just
like
something
out
of
the
varieties
of
religious
experience
by
William
James.
You
are
saying,
now
go
back
down
and
finish
reading
that
book.
And
that
was
the
first
woman
that
kept
the
gift
of
sobriety.
That
was
a
woman
because
of
the
suffering
she
had
in
her
life,
went
out
and
founded
the
National
Council
on
Alcoholism,
which
changed
the
way
the
medical
profession
and
the
legal
profession
view
alcoholism.
What
are
the
fruits
of
that
experience?
Again,
this
is
Sam
Shoemaker
talking
about
the
experience.
And
Sam
says,
I
believe...
that
it
is
a
relatively
sudden
manner
for
many
and
a
combination
of
suddenness
and
gradualness
for
others.
I
believe
that
it
is
likely
to
be
an
experience
which
takes
place
at
a
definite
and
recognized
time.
James
wrote,
self-surrender
has
been
and
always
must
be
regarded
as
the
vital
turning
point
of
religious
life.
And
again,
instead
of
using
the
medieval
religious,
we
could
say,
of
spiritual
life.
Now,
I'd
like
to
wrap
up
with
a
little
bit
about
Jung
and
his
analysis
of
alcoholism,
this
disease
that
I
have,
that
he
wrote
in
the
response
to
the
letter
that
Jason
was
kind
enough
to
read
earlier.
Now,
Jung's
analysis
of
Roland
was
this.
His
craving
for
alcohol
was
the
equivalent
on
a
low
level
of
the
spiritual
thirst
of
our
being
for
wholeness
expressed
in
medieval
language,
union
with
God.
And
I
don't
know
about
you,
but
when
I
drank,
I
was
complete,
and
I'd
never
been
complete
before.
I
had
always
been
a
divided
self.
But
when
I
drank,
I
became
complete.
And
it
worked
for
as
long
as
it
worked,
and
then
it
left.
And
Jung
goes
on
to
say
that
you
might
be
led
to
that
goal,
the
path
out
of
alcoholism,
by
an
act
of
grace,
a
sudden
experience,
or
through
a
personal
and
honest
contact
with
friends.
going
to
meetings.
Or
through
a
higher
education
of
the
mind,
beyond
the
confines
of
mere
rationalism.
I
see
from
your
letter
that
Roland
has
chosen
the
second
way.
In
other
words,
he
was
going
to
the
meetings.
So
I'd
like
to
take
a
couple
of
minutes,
just
a
few.
Take
three
minutes
and
we'll
meditate
together.
And
what
I'd
like
you
to
do,
if
you
would,
is
join
me
and
close
your
eyes
and
breathe
in
and
breathe
out.
And
ask
yourself
these
questions
about
your
experience.
Was
yours
sudden
or
gradual?
When
did
it
happen?
Who
led
you
to
this
experience
and
what
are
the
fruits?
Thank
you.
Bill
Wilson
talked
on
and
on
in
the
last
years
of
his
life.
And
I
highly
recommend
that
you
go
to
grapevine.org.
or
you
Google
spiritual
experience
and
read
the
articles
that
he
wrote
or
the
transcripts
of
talks
that
he
gave
to,
and
I'm
sure
our
taper
can
get
it
for
us.
It's
a
talk
that
he
gave
on
spiritual
experience
to
a
group
of
recovering
priests
in
1966.
And
in
it
he
talks
about
the
fact
that
too
much
emphasis
is
put
on
the
people
that
have
had
a
sudden
experience,
that
somehow
they've
been
made
something
special.
when
the
fact
is
that
the
only
difference
is
the
time
factor.
He
said,
in
me,
it
all
came
at
once.
And
other
people,
it
may
take
years.
But
the
fruits
are
the
same.
We're
not
drinking
and
we're
carrying
a
vital
message.
He
said
that
we'll
sit
there
in
the
meeting
and
you'll
hear
some
guy
get
up
and
say,
I
don't
know
about
this
spiritual
stuff.
I've
heard
about
Bill
and
his
hot
flash,
and
I
don't
get
any
of
that.
But
you
know,
I
got
a
wife
who's
happy
to
see
me
come
home.
I
got
an
employer
that
trusts
me.
My
children
don't
shrink
when
I
walk
in
the
room.
And
Bill
says,
we
all
know
that's
the
deal.
There
is
no
more
than
that.
And
yet
this
person
says,
I
don't
get
the
spiritual
angle.
We
only
know
that
he
hasn't
gotten
to
the
point
that
he
says
the
words.
Now,
in
this
room,
there's
probably
at
least
20
people
that
have
had
one
of
the
sudden
white
light
experiences.
Right.
I
was
nine
months
sober,
eight
months
sober,
seven
months.
I
don't
know.
I
was
sitting
in
a
room
and
the
room
left.
And
I
sat
there.
It
was
nothing
but
white.
I
could
feel
the
consciousness
of
the
chair
underneath
me
and
gradually
that
there
were
people
around
me.
But
my
mind
said,
this
must
be
an
LSD
flashback.
And
my
heart
said,
no,
no,
no,
pay
attention.
And
I
did.
And
what
was
there
was
what's
called
in
classical
language,
the
peace
that
passes
understanding.
There
are
no
words.
There
are
no
ways
that
you
can
take
these
syllables
and
wrap
it
around
an
experience
like
that.
The
best
I
can
tell
you
is
I
knew
that
everything
was
known
and
everything
was
okay.
But
an
alcoholic
males
involved.
So
I
come
up
with
a
question.
And
I
say,
what
about
war
in
my
mind?
And
the
feeling
was,
wasn't
an
answer,
it
was
a
feeling.
Don't
worry,
I
got
it.
And
then
I
sat
there
and
for
another
few
minutes,
I
don't
know
how
long
it
was,
maybe
six,
maybe
eight,
maybe
12.
Okay.
And
I
started
to
ask
another
question.
I
was
going
for
the
abortion
card.
And
just
as
I
even
started
to
form
it,
the
feeling
came
again,
don't
worry,
I
got
it.
And
I
sat
there
in
the
presence.
And
then
after
a
time,
the
woman
who
was
speaking
was
Liz
La
Presti.
And
the
moment
had
come
when
she
was
saying
that
I
drank
away
my
soul,
that
I
drank
away
everything
that
makes
a
human
being,
a
human
being.
And
I
was
left
nothing
but
an
animal.
And
at
that
moment
I
went,
pooh.
And
then
she
was
still
talking
as
the
room
started
to
come
back
in.
And
at
this
place,
the
Westwood
Community
Church,
there
are
three
stained
glass
windows.
And
that
was
the
first
thing
that
came
into
my
vision,
and
it's
God
is
love.
And
I
looked
around,
and
I
was
scared.
And
it
was
apparent
to
me
that
nobody
else
had
been
through
the
door
that
I'd
been
through.
And
so
I
kept
my
mouth
closed.
And
I
didn't
say
anything
about
it
for
a
while.
And,
uh,
And
a
few
weeks
later,
it's
late
at
night,
I'm
talking
to
an
old
timer
over
coffee.
And
the
old
timer
said,
oh,
yeah,
kid,
that
happens
all
the
time.
But
we
don't
say
anything
because
we
don't
want
to
scare
the
newcomer.
I
said
one
thing
about
it
at
a
meeting
one
time,
a
guy
came
over
their
chair
at
me,
calling
me
a
liar.
So
I
didn't
say
anything.
The
AA
that
I
came
into,
not
only
could
we
read
the
book
unsupervised,
but
people
were
coming
over
chairs
and
things
were
flying
and
stuff.
It
was
a
great
time
to
get
sober.
And
I
looked
up
my
old
parish
priest,
and
I
said
to
him,
this
is
what
happened.
And
what
he
did
is
he
went
back
to
James,
and
he
also
told
me,
he
said,
I
wish
that
that
was
my
story.
He
said,
but
it's
not.
He
said,
I
wish
with
all
my
heart
that
that
was
my
story,
but
it's
not.
He
said,
but
I've
had
a
couple
of
parishioners
over
the
years,
and
this
is
what
has
happened.
This
is
happening
all
the
time.
And
it's
sudden
or
it's
gradual,
but
it's
the
same
experience
because
what's
the
fruits
of
the
experience?
I'm
still
with
you
and
I'm
still
sober.
And
I'm
doing
my
best
to
carry
this
message.
And
for
me,
the
tragedy
in
my
life
is
that
I
lived
for
20
years
as
if
the
experience
didn't
happen.
I
just
kept
it
tucked
away
in
my
heart
and
I
didn't
live
risking
deeply,
loving
fearlessly,
all
the
time,
knowing
that
all
is
okay
and
all
is
known.
Carl
Jung
ends
his
letter
to
Bill
Wilson
with
this
formula.
He
says,
you
see
alcohol
in
Latin
is
spiritus.
And
you
use
the
same
word
for
the
highest
religious
experience
as
well
as
for
the
most
depraving
poison.
The
helpful
formula,
therefore,
is
spiritus
contra
spiritum,
the
spirit
of.
using
medieval
language,
God,
against
the
spirits
of
alcohol.
Thank
you.