The Spiritual Experience It's a Matter of Grace
Hey,
well
now
sit
down
after
all
of
this,
doesn't
it?
Well,
I
like
the
informal
discussion
type
of
approach.
It
seemed
to
me
that
on
occasion
like
this
questions
or
something
of
intimately
more
value
than
a
lecture
or
a
story.
But
Rip
suggested
that
I
make
some
remarks
here
tonight,
and
I'm
only
too
glad
to
do
that.
And
coming
down
on
the
plane,
I
got
speculating
with
myself
about
the
early
days
of
a
A
and
about
the
the
meaning
of
them
in
terms
of
the
grace
of
God.
I've
read
somewhere
that
if
a
grain
of
wheat,
which
has
been
stored
for
centuries
in
a
dry
place,
is
exposed
to
the
right
soil
and
the
right
climate
and
to
enough
light
from
above,
it
will
manifest
life
and
it
will
unfold
and
it
will
grow.
But
this
presupposes
the
right
soil,
the
right
climate,
and
above
all,
enough
life.
Well,
I
think
it's
that
way
with
a
A
I
remember
years
back
when
we
first
began
to
get
publicity
and
the
first
very
large
occasion
was
a
feature
piece
done
in
the
Saturday
Evening
Post,
which
all
at
once
produced
us
about
6000
members.
This
was
in
41
and
by
then
a
number
of
medics
had
become
close
friends,
some
of
them
psychiatrists,
and
these
fellows
allowed
their
names
to
be
used,
or
rather
audacious
step
in
those
days.
I
assure
you
your
names
were
used
in
the
Post
article.
I
make
this
point
because
the
one
later
asked
to
testify
on
another
occasion,
they
refused
to
do
it
and
these
were
the
circumstances.
The
first
GAL
that
got
sober
in
a
A
is
one
known
to
many
of
you
as
Marty.
Still
very
much
of
A
growing
concern
in
the
education
field,
Marty
was
the
most
difficult
case.
Glad
knows
we're
all
complex,
but
Marty
was
really
a
chance,
and
she
had
been
under
the
care
of
a
doctor.
Foster
Kennedy,
a
man
of
very
wide
repute
in
that
time
worldwide,
renowned
a
neurologist,
and
he
watched
Marley
as
she
was
planted
in
the
new
soil.
He
watched
her
receive
this
light
well.
He
was
tremendously
impressed.
He
came
to
some
meetings
and
soon
he
said
the
main
bell.
Would
it
be
possible
to
have
two
or
three
of
the
psychiatrists
in
institutions
who
have
seen
recoveries
of
very
grim
cases,
people
that
you
say
are
friends
with
yours
and
who
have
testified
for
you
in
the
post
piece?
Couldn't
we
get
a
group
of
this
thought
to
come
to
the
Academy
of
Medicine
and
explain
what
they
have
seen?
Well,
we
thought
this
was
just
great
because
in
those
days
there
were
a
few
friends
indeed
saw
showing
by
these
people
by
reason
of
Doctor
Kennedy.
Well,
what
could
be
better?
So
one
by
one
we
went
to
them
and
we
said
would
they
come
to
the
Academy?
And
we
supposed
they
would.
After
all,
some
of
the
Canada
glory
could
brush
off,
and
you
know,
they
were
friends
anyhow,
and
they
proved
it,
so
why
not?
And
not
a
one
would
do
it.
And
when
pressed
for
their
reasons
for
not
doing
it,
each
one
of
them
separately
said
the
same
thing.
In
effect,
each
said
look
fell.
You
folks
have
added
up
in
one
column
more
of
the
resources
which
have
been
separately
applied
to
Alcoholics
than
anyone
else.
For
example,
you
have
this
kinship
in
supper.
You
have
possibilities
of
communication
that
others
don't
have.
You
have
a
crude
form
of
self
examination
or
analysis
and
our
catharsis.
You
have
a
great
new
outgoing
interest.
You
reduce
guilt
by
restitution
and
you
have
this
great,
compelling
interest
in
helping
others.
And
then
there
is
a
religious
fact.
And
then
there
is
this
factor
of
the
hopelessness,
so
far
as
the
resources
of
the
individual
are
concerned,
of
this
melon.
Now
this
is
a
formidable
list.
Our
forces
that
we
still
can't
come
to
the
Academy.
Well,
why
not?
Well
said.
They
we
see
in
a
A
sometimes
in
which
in
a
few
months
shifts
in
motivation
that
even
the
sum
of
these
forces
couldn't
begin
to
account
for.
Because
we
all
do
well
understand
the
difficulties
of
this
problem.
There's
subtle
compulsion
and
the
some
of
them
won't
add
up
to
the
speed
of
these
transformations
in
these
very
grim
cases.
So
for
us,
there
is
an
unknown
factor
at
work
in
a
A
and
among
ourselves
being
scientists,
we
call
it
The
X
Factor.
We
believe
you
people
call
it
the
grace
of
God.
And
who
shall
go
to
the
Academy
to
explain
the
grace
of
God
to
God
Father?
No
one
can,
and
we
simply
aren't
wrong.
So
I
think
it
is
just
as
futile
as
average
for
any
of
us
to
presume
to
explain
dense
matter
of
grace
around
which
our
entire
Galaxy
of
principles
and
activities
challenge
and
clusters.
We
can't
do
that,
But
we
can
examine
this
matter
of
the
sort
and
this
matter
of
time
and
this
matter
of
illumination
which
for
some
reason
or
other
we
have
made
ourselves
ready.
Clearly
God's
grace
is
in
and
through
all.
So,
it
might
be
said,
why
have
an
alcoholic
sobered
many
times
more
often
through
grace
in
the
head?
It's
available.
Why
hasn't
religion
been
more
successful,
numerically
at
least?
Why
hasn't
medicine
done
more
success?
How
is
it
that
laymen
seem
to
be
doing
this
thing?
So
I
would
like
to
tell
a
story
depicting,
at
least
as
it
seems
to
me,
what
the
soil
is
and
what
the
climate
is
and
what
the
light
is.
These
things
of
which
we
have
been
placed
in
such
tragic
possession,
there
is
no
doubt
that
in
an
ordinary
sense
of
Tom
Air
began
in
the
office
of
a
psychiatrist.
And
we
might
be
mindful
of
this
when
we
criticize
people
in
this
profession.
Of
course,
for
most
of
us,
the
origin
is
2000
years
old,
for
some
of
us
perhaps
older.
But
I'm
Speaking
of
the
situation
in
an
immediate
sense.
How
was
it
precipitated
this
sense?
This,
too,
is
a
matter
of
conjecture,
but
here's
how
it
seems
to
me.
There
was
a
certain
businessman
of
great
attainment.
He's
cut
down
by
the
grind.
He
runs
the
gamut
of
treatments
in
this
country
and
this
would
be
in
the
year
about
1932
when
he
was
just
about
at
the
end
of
his
tether.
So
he
went
abroad
and
became
a
patient
of
Doctor
Carl
Yung.
And
as
all
of
you
know,
you
was
one
of
the
founding
fathers
of
the
art.
I
prefer
that
instead
of
Science
of
psychiatry
and
you,
Oddler,
Freud
were
the
three
founding
fathers.
But
of
these
only
you
seem
to
think
that
man
is
something
more
than
$2.00
worth
of
chemicals,
a
bundle
of
instincts
and
an
uncertain
intellect.
Young
soul
man
has
something
beyond
this.
That
man
has
salt.
So
our
traveler
had
found
a
truly
great
human
being.
Great
indeed,
as
events
sell
out,
he
placed
himself
under
that
dear
man's
2
lynch
for
a
whole
year,
becoming
more
and
more
confident
where
the
hidden
springs
of
this
baleful
compassion
to
drink.
We're
being
understood
and
removes
and
attached
to
what?
He
began
to
feel
more
free.
There
was
number
drinking
while
he
was
under
treat.
At
the
end
of
the
year
he
left
Carl
Jung
and
in
one
month
he
was
tight
and
the
Bender
was
terrific.
So
in
infinite
despair,
he
came
back
to
call
you
and
said,
is
there
anything
now
for
me?
You
were
my
court
of
last
resort
and
this
great
man,
said
Roland.
I
thought
for
a
time
after
you
first
tint
that
you
might
be
one
of
those
rare
cases
in
which
my
art
has
been
helpful.
Otherwise,
I
should
not
have
encouraged
you
to
stay.
But
alas,
I'm
obliged
to
conclude
that
you
are
not,
and
that
there
is
nothing
that
I
have
to
offer
you.
My
art
has
failed
you.
I
need
not
say
that
coming
from
a
man
of
His
Eminence,
this
was
a
statement.
How
beautiful
humility
and
the
whole
destiny
of
a
A,
you
and
me
and
all
of
us
has
since
hung
on
that
sentence.
So
then
Hazard
found
that
agony
was
added
to
dispel
and
he
cried
out.
But
is
there
nothing
else?
And
this
was
the
answer
he
got.
Rowan
Time
out
of
mine.
Alcoholics
have
recovered
here
and
there
now
and
then
through
religious
experiences,
spiritual
experiences,
let
us
say
our
very
truly
through
conversion,
a
naughty
word
for
our
says
we
don't
use
it
for
obviously.
But,
said
the
doctor,
this
benign
lightning
seldom
strike,
and
no
one
can
say
where
or
when
it
will,
or
for
the
resuscitation
of
food.
So
I
simply
would
advise
you
to
place
yourself
in
a
religious
atmosphere,
remembering
the
hopelessness
of
your
doing
anything
about
it
on
your
own,
remaining
resources
alone
and
cooperating
where
your
associates
and
casting
yourself
upon
whatever
God
there
may
be.
So
Roland
aligned
himself
with
the
Oxford
Groups
of
that
time
are
rather
evangelical
movement,
rather
aggressive.
How
easy
it
is
to
criticize.
It
was
non
denominational
however,
and
it
used
simple
common
denominators.
Our
religions
simple
moral
principles.
It
called
upon
its
members
to
admit
that
they
could
not
solve
the
life
problem
on
their
own.
It
called
upon
them
for
self
examination,
called
upon
them
for
restitution.
It
called
upon
them
for
a
kind
of
giving
in
the
Franciscan
manner,
the
kind
of
giving
that
demands
no
return
in
money,
power,
prestige,
and
the
life,
the
losing
of
1
S
in
the
lives
of
others.
Such
was
the
nature
of
the
crowd
with
which
he
became
associate.
Unaccountably
to
him,
the
exception
to
drink
left,
and
for
some
years
he
had
no
more
trouble.
At
the
time
in
the
groups
there
were
a
few
alcoholic
sober.
There
is
one
now
at
Ann
Arbor
that
goes
back
to
that
time.
An
old
friend
who
never
became
an
A
A
sober
up
in
the
Oxford
Groups.
So
Roland
returned
to
America.
And
the
groups
here
in
those
days
were
headed
by
an
Episcopal
clergyman
called
Sam
Shoemaker.
And
in
his
congregation
and
among
the
groups
were
two
or
three
other
Alcoholics
that
for
the
nonce
for
staying
Broad
and
Hazard,
had
a
summer
place
near
Bennington,
Vt.
And
these
friends,
one
of
them
son
of
a
local
judge
and
himself
an
alcoholic,
described
the
plight
of
a
boy
who
was
at
school
time
chamomant.
Happy.
Thatcher
and
Abby
had
been
deteriorating
horribly.
They
were
summer
folks
in
the
town
above
Manchester.
Abby
had
run
his
car
into
the
side
of
the
farmer's
house,
pushed
the
wall
of
the
kitchen
in
the
door
was
would
still
be
open
to
the
car.
Abby
stuck
his
head
out
into
the
poor
woman
cowering
in
the
corner
who
hadn't
been
hit.
He
said.
Hey,
what
about
a
cup
of
coffee?
Well,
the
town
fathers
had
had
it.
They
were
going
to
commit
Abby
an
alcoholic
insanity.
So
the
judges
son
and
Hazard
picked
up
the
man
who
was
to
become
my
sponsor.
Meanwhile,
I
had
gone
the
route
with
what
you're
all
familiar.
I
had
sobered
up
the
summer
before,
scared
to
death
by
the
verdict
of
my
doctor,
Doctor
Selfwood.
The
one
we
have
since
named
the
little
Doctor
Who
loved
drums,
and
he
must
of
them
because
in
his
lifetime
he
dealt
with
some
40,000
of
them
as
a
hack
doctor
in
a
drawing
out
place.
And
he
had
an
idea
that
this
thing
was
an
illness
having
several
components,
a
spiritual
illness,
a
moral
illness,
also
a
physical
illness.
And
perhaps
oversimplifying,
he
was
apartment
to
describe
an
alcoholic
as
a
person
condemned
by
a
compulsion
to
drink
against
his
own
interests,
to
drink
in
spite
of
a
perfect
willingness
to
stop.
And
this
drinking
was
coupled
to
an
increasing
sensitivity
of
the
body.
White
shifted.
Drinking
went
on,
guaranteed
his
insanity
and
one
day
his
death.
So
this
sort
of
a
sentence
had
been
spoken
to
Lois
at
long
last
by
my
doctor,
Doctor
Selfport.
So
you
see,
the
saw
was
under
preparation.
We
were
beginning
to
learn
a
little
more
about
climate.
Abby
and
my
other
friend
Roland
had
received
a
considerable
amount
of
life.
Well,
I
got
drunk
in
about
two
months.
Even
in
spite
of
this
sentence
that
I
would
have
to
be
locked
up.
I
have
gone
nuts.
Maybe
within
a
year.
And
then
my
friend
Abby,
who
had
been
brought
to
New
York
and
Vermont,
who
had
unaccountably
sobered
up
for
the
time
being
in
the
Oxford
groups,
came
to
visit
me.
But
I
too
was
in
great
respect.
Despair
is
a
primary
ingredient,
indeed,
of
this
sort.
In
the
medical
jargon,
we
might
call
it
deflation.
At
depth,
some
deflation.
So
Abby
came
to
see
me,
and
he
tasted
me.
This
list
of
more,
you
might
say?
Cliches.
Nothing
so
new
about
that.
I
was
in
favor
of
honesty.
I
was
in
favor
of
helping
other
people.
I
was
in
favor
of
practically
everything
he
had
to
say
except
one
say.
I
was
not
in
favor
of
God,
for
I
had
received
one
of
these
magnificent
model
modern
schoolings,
scientific
schooling
that
assured
that
by
a
series
of
stages
picking
up
in
four
months
from
somewhere
as
they
went
along,
I
could
be
traced
back
to
a
single
piece
of
ooze
and
prehistoric
seas.
And
this
was
my
face,
and
science
was
my
God.
So
along
comes
Abby,
and
along
comes
you,
for
whom
I
had
respect,
and
here
was
my
doctor.
Science
can't
do
it.
Medicine
can't
do
it.
Psychology
can't
do
it.
Religion.
Sometimes
that
was
the
stars.
But
how
could
I
buy
religion?
So
I
felt
trapped
in
either
words.
I
was
gripped
in
the
trap
which
we
every
day
construct
for
the
drunk
or
poaches
us
saying
well
I
think
the
group
life
must
be
great
helping
other
people
and
for
it.
But
I
couldn't
get
the
spiritual
angle
as
our
jargon
has
now.
As
you
know,
this
gentleman
is
the
newcomer
like
me
is
being
caught
in
this
trap.
When
you
and
I
talk
to
another
alcoholic
and
we
identify
ourselves
as
having
been
denizens
of
this
strange
world
and
having
emerged,
and
we
describe
this
malady
in
the
terms
of
our
God's
science
and
that
God
pronounces
the
sense
of
hopelessness
on
us.
The
sentence
We
are
deflated
at
depth
and
then
we
learn
that
now
we
have
accepted
our
personal
hopelessness,
there
still
isn't
any
hope
because
we
cannot
go
through
the
God
business.
And
this
was
the
awful
Dylan
into
which
I
was
cast
by
my
friend
Abby,
bringing
on
the
one
side
all
of
this
bad
news,
but
on
the
other
side
the
spectacle
of
his
own
release.
And
that
was
the
word
he
used.
He
didn't
say
he
was
on
the
waterway.
The
obsession
had
just
left
it
as
soon
as
he
became
world
to
trap
on
the
basis
of
these
principles,
and
indeed
as
he
became
willing
to
appeal
to
whatever
God
there
might
be.
And
this
was
reducing
the
theological
requirements
an
awful
lot.
Well,
I
went
on
drinking
the
boat.
Spring
Link
and
in
no
waking
hour,
but
I
forget
the
face
of
my
friend.
I
respectful
of
release
as
I
looked
out
through
a
haze
of
Gin
and
Ruth's
face
as
he
pitched
this
sentences
at
me.
A
conversion
experience
is
not
for
me.
I'm
an
obstinate
Vermonter.
Besides,
I
can't,
I
can't
fight.
People
say
to
me
have
faith,
and
I
believe
I'd
have
faith
if
I
could
have
it,
but
I
can't.
But
anyhow,
I'll
go
and
get
dried
up.
So
I
went
to
the
hospital.
I
must
have
had
a
little
optimism
because
I
came
in
with
a
bag
of
beer.
I
tried
to
share
it
on
the
subway
up.
I
was
waving
a
bottle.
Their
little
Doctor
Silkworth
came
out
and
I
yelled
at
him.
This
time,
Doctor,
I
got
it,
he
said.
I'm
afraid
you
have
Bill.
You
better
get
upstairs
and
go
to
bed.
And
he
looked
very
sad
for
he
loved
me.
So
I
went
upstairs
and
went
to
bed.
I
was
there
while
ahead
of
the
DTS,
so
in
about
3
days.
All
in
the
clear,
But
the
more
sober
I
got,
the
more
awful
the
despair,
the
depression.
So
I
think
it
was
the
morning
of
the
3rd
to
the
4th
day
that
my
friend
Abby
showed
up
in
the
doorway
and
my
feeling
was
ambivalent
at
once.
So
I
said,
well,
this
is
the
time
he's
going
to
pour
on
the
evangelist.
And
on
the
other
hand,
I
was
saying,
well,
he
should
be
looking
for
a
job.
Why
is
he
up
there
at
11:00
in
the
morning
seeing
me?
He
does
practice
what
he
preaches.
So
Abby
knew
my
prejudices.
So
he
waited
for
me
to
ask
him
again
for
that
neat
little
formula
through
which
he
had
achieved
relief
and
dutifully
went
through
it.
You
got
honest
with
yourself,
with
another
person
in
confidence.
You
made
restitution,
you
helped
others,
and
you
prayed
to
God
as
you
understood
it.
I
think
you
might
have
even
used
that
choice.
And
without
much
more
ado,
he
was
strong.
No
pressure
and
again
I
could
have
trucks
with
God.
And
again
the
despair
deeper
until
the
last
of
this
prideful
absence
seat
momentarily
was
apparently
crushed
up.
And
then,
like
a
child
crying
out
in
the
dark,
I
said,
If
there
is
a
father,
if
there
is
a
godly
show
himself.
And
the
place
lit
up
in
great
glare,
our
wondrous
white
life.
And
then
I
began
to
have
images
in
the
mind's
eye,
so
to
speak,
and
one
came
in
which
I
seemed
to
see
myself
standing
on
a
mountain,
and
a
great
clean
wind
was
blown.
And
it's
blowing
at
first
went
around,
and
then
it
seemed
to
go
through.
And
then
the
ecstasy
redoubled
and
I
found
myself
exclaiming.
I
am
free
men,
so
this
is
the
God
of
the
torture.
And
little
by
little,
they
actually
subsided,
and
I
found
myself
in
a
new
world
of
consciousness
and
one
of
the
earliest
reflections
in
this
world
of
great
peace.
We
stole
over
Maine.
Why
is
that?
All
is
well
with
God.
I
am
a
part
of
this
cosmos
at
Flash.
Even
evil
be
in
his
hands
can
be
transmuted
into
good.
So
I
had
been
deflated
at
depth.
Buy
a
fellow
software.
Oh
yes,
the
scientific
verdict
to
deflate
me.
Who
used
his
ability
to
communicate
me
through
our
kinship
of
common
suffering
and
who
made
the
extent
I
have
a
person
who
practiced
for
the
police.
So
then
for
me
here
indeed.
Why
is
this
soft?
There
was
one,
and
God
knows
the
light
of
his
prayer.
Now
I
venture
this
assertion
was
of
a
A
has
a
spiritual
awakening
or
experience
of
exactly
this
character.
Certainly
it
is
not
for
me
to
differ
with
theologians,
but
let
me
say
I
prefer
to
think
that
there
is
no
essential
difference
between
what
happened
to
me
and
what
happened
to
leave
sound
a
a
accepting
the
time
going
back
to
those
five
who
said
we
can't
understand
this
tremendous
shift
in
motivation
despite
all
your
resources.
Well,
in
my
case
the
shift.
But
the
fruits
have
been
the
same,
and
one
of
the
most
terrible
compulsions
and
obsessions
known
has
been
expelled
from
us
almost
wholesale
through
this
happy
sentences
of
medicine,
religion
and
our
own
experience
in
suffering,
in
recovery
and
sharing
the
grace
of
this
one
with
the
next.
So
fellas,
there's
my
speech.
Is
that
light
relative
in
the
sense
of
elimination?
Must
be
not
everyone
of
us
has
gone
through
the
experience
of
ecstasy
or
and
the
light
shining.
OK,
maybe
you
know,
this
is
a
curbstone
opinion,
but
here's
how
I
look
in
You
go
to
a
a
meeting
and
somebody
gets
up
when
this
happens
time
after
time
and
he
says
now
folks,
I
ain't
got
to
spiritual
angle.
Yeah,
I'm
making
the
group
my
higher
power.
They're
sober
and
I
was.
So
I
got
a
higher
power,
but
I
ain't
got
spiritual
angle
the
way
you
probably
did.
And
As
for
Bill's
thing,
well,
he
looked
sane
in
other
respects.
But
you
know,
now
this
guy
will
get
up
there
and
tell
a
story
of
losing
this
compulsion
and
if
it's
being
cleared
out
of
them
and
it's
being
remorted,
motivated
in
many
other
ways,
just
like
those
who
have
said
in
a
matter
of
months
or
six
months
or
a
year.
Now
just
take
one
of
those
fellows
and
try
to
imagine
all
of
those
shifts
in
motivation
taking
place
within
six
months
or
within
6
minutes
instead
of
six
months.
I
think
as
this
happened
to
that
fellow,
he
too
would
have
had
ecstasy.
So
I
think
it's
a
time
element
and
I
personally
see
no
great
advantage
in
these
tremendous
experiences.
Saving
my
case
only
once
it
it
did
give
me
an
instant
fiction
of
the
presence
of
God,
which
has
never
left
me
from
that
month
in
spite
of
the
worst
iPhone
doe.
And
it's
often
been
damn
bad.
And
no
matter
what
pressure.
And
I
feel
that
that
extra
dividend
may
have
made
the
difference
whether
I
would
have
persisted
with
a
A
in
the
early
years
or
not.
Actually,
it
has
some
liabilities
and
I've
seen
it
in
others
who
have
had
these
experiences
in
IA
and
there
are
quite
a
lot.
And
this
is
the
Cannon
City
and
I
think
you've
seen
logs
give
us
some
excuse
for
it
too.
Are
beginning
to
think
that
because
we
have
these
tremendous
illuminations
that
we
are
something
special.
So
you
begin
to
develop
a
kind
of
a
paranoia
alongside
are
a
perfectly
valid
experience
and
this
is
just
what
happened
to
me.
I
damn
near
botched
up
the
whole
world
by
coming
out
of
this
working
curiously
with
drunks,
and
before
anybody
had
been
sobered
up,
I
got
so
far
off
base
as
to
loudly
declare,
one
time
to
an
audience
by
no
means
spellbound,
that
I
was
going
to
sober
up
all
the
God
damn
drunks
in
the
world.
Now
that
is
pure
paranoia,
so
don't
long
for
the
illumination.
I
think
you're
apartment
to
have
the
experience
that's
appropriate.
Why
not
longing
for
it?
Well,
some
people
do,
you
know.
Oh
my
God,
if
I
can
only
have
one
like
Bill.
Now
actually,
this
may
be
said
very
sincerely
because
this
may
be
guys
slipping
around,
but
he
may
be
slipping
around
on
account
of
the
fact
that
he's
a
little
sketchy
and
needs
some
of
them
vitamin
B3.
So
now
we're
put
on
Hawking.